Anti-Krugman 9: Talk Sense
Sunday, October 22nd, 2006Paul Krugman rants in tomorrow’s Times about how the Democrats should speak up if they win the House. Last week, he said this means spending 10% of the House’s floor time investigating the administration. This time he added Nancy Pelosi’s agenda item:
according to opinion polls, most Americans are actually to the left of Congressional Democrats on issues such as health care.
In particular, the public wants politicians to stand up to corporate interests. This is clear from the latest Newsweek poll, which shows overwhelming public support for the agenda Nancy Pelosi has laid out for her first 100 hours if she becomes House speaker. The strongest support is for her plan to have Medicare negotiate with drug companies for lower prices, which is supported by 74 percent of Americans — and by 70 percent of Republicans!
The first problem with this proposal is that Medicare has been captured by the drug companies and if they are empowered to do price controls, they will push prices up rather than down. Legislating lower prices is like trying to legislate the value of pi to be 3. It doesn’t work.